Screens, school, and home
The best preparation for a digital future is an analog education
Since speaking on the RSU 21 School Board’s technology panel, I keep coming back to one idea. The kids who will handle technology best as adults are the ones who first learned with their hands and with each other.
By Colleen Fradette, LMHC, LCPC
We learned technology just fine
Most of us grew up without a device for every student. We had a computer lab, or a few computers in the library, and we navigate technology just fine. That’s because we were taught the foundations first: creative thinking, problem solving, and executive functioning. Those skills get blunted when access comes too early. We cut off the learning that was supposed to happen before the screen.
Analog learning matters because the more you do with your hands and through interacting with other people, the more you learn.
Brains take the easy route
Our brains look for the easiest way to get something done. Every living creature is wired that way, because it improves the odds of survival. That isn’t a flaw in kids. It’s biology. But it means that when the easiest route is always on offer, kids will take it, and they miss the effort that builds the skill. Our job as adults is to stop only providing the easiest route.
School and home used to build these skills together
School and home used to work on executive functioning side by side. In both places, we repeatedly had to start a task, push through it, and finish it, often a task we didn’t want to do. We also had to learn to manage our emotions about all of it. Technology, in many ways, has stripped away those skill-building moments.
In a perfect world, parents would limit what their kids have access to, so kids weren’t arriving at school thinking about who did or said what on social media. They could come to school to learn and to be with each other in person.
Foundations first: typing is a good example
If we expect kids to do their work on computers, we should teach them to type. Typing with two index fingers is not just as quick. It isn’t. A child hunting for keys is spending mental energy on getting words onto the screen instead of on the thinking and the writing.
AI is already on the device
A lot of the conversation about kids and AI treats it as something to keep away from them. But the computers we hand kids often have AI built right in, and it may not be something a school can switch off. If we’re deciding how kids should and shouldn’t use AI, we need to start by knowing what’s already on the machine.
Questions you can ask your child’s school
None of these are gotcha questions. Schools are working through the same problems families are, and good answers help everyone.
- What technology do teachers use for instruction at my child’s grade, and what platforms do students have access to?
- Does the school use an allow list of approved websites or a block list of banned ones?
- Have the sites and apps students use been vetted for privacy and data practices? What data is collected, and how is it used?
- How is student activity on school accounts and devices monitored, and who is responsible for watching it?
- Is there AI built into school devices or accounts, and can it be turned off?
- Is typing taught, and in what grade?
- What does the research say about technology compared with teacher-led instruction, and does that research come from outside the companies that make the products?
- If our family wants to limit one-to-one device use, while keeping the curriculum, what options are there?
What you can do at home
- Favor hands and people. Learning that happens with real materials and other people sticks.
- Let kids finish the hard thing. Starting, sticking with, and completing tasks they don’t love, and handling the frustration along the way, is executive functioning practice.
- Hold off where you can. The later personal devices and social media arrive, the more of the school day kids get to spend learning and with each other.
- Treat the school as a partner. Ask questions, share what you see at home, and look for ways to work on the same skills in both places.
The question underneath all of this is how we make it a team effort. That’s much of what I do with parents: changing routines at home so kids get the repetitions they need. How parent sessions work.
Next step
Start with a free 15‑minute call.
I don’t expect you to know much. Therapy is often new, and intimidating, and most people arrive without the words for what’s going on. Helping you find them is part of the work.
The form asks for a few basics: your contact information, where you’re located, and roughly what’s bringing you in. I’m accepting new clients, weekdays from 9 AM to 2 PM.
- Fill out a short intake (about 5 minutes)
- I reply within one business day
- We talk for 15 minutes, free
This opens a secure intake form through SimplePractice, the system I use for my practice. It takes about 5 minutes. It’s not a login. Please don’t send clinical or personal health details by regular email or text, because those aren’t secure. Prefer to talk first? Call (978) 219-9522. This form isn’t monitored for emergencies. If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 or call 911.