RSU 21 School Board panel · May 27, 2026
Screens, friction, and the skills kids need
In May 2026, the RSU 21 School Board, which serves Arundel, Kennebunk, and Kennebunkport, held a public workshop called “Exploring the Impact of Technology on Learning.” I was asked to join the panel and answer its first question. Below are the question and my remarks, lightly edited for reading.
By Colleen Fradette, LMHC, LCPC · Watch the recording (my remarks start at about 13:50)
The question
So much of the discussion around technology in schools these days focuses on cell phones and AI and their positions as unsanctioned or disruptive technology. But we have seemingly accepted school-sponsored Chromebooks for each student, even in elementary grades.
How should we be thinking about screen time and gamification of learning in relation to school-provided technology and tools targeted to augment them (such as YouTube and learning-based computer games)? What is developmentally appropriate, in your opinion, and educationally effective at different grade levels?
In addition to learning, does the use of technology in the classroom pose a threat to social and emotional development?
My answer
I want to start by saying that I’m not anti-technology. I use it, I value it, and I think there are places where it genuinely serves students well. But we have a cultural habit of assuming the newer upgrade is automatically the better one. In doing so, we sometimes skip foundations that matter more than we realize, and trade away things we didn’t know we needed until they were gone.
The friction that used to build skills
When I was growing up, watching a movie required a small odyssey. You had to convince your parents, get driven to the video store, and hope the movie wasn’t already rented. If it was, you had to manage that disappointment in the moment, make a different choice, and try again another time. Nobody designed those moments as character-building exercises. They were just friction, the ordinary resistance that life used to offer. Developing brains need that resistance. It’s how skills get built.
My work as a therapist is largely focused on skills like distress tolerance, emotion regulation, empathy, perspective taking, and interpersonal communication. The brain doesn’t simply develop these on its own. They take intention and repetition. Over the course of my career I’ve watched the world provide fewer of those repetitions naturally: the ordinary moments of waiting, disappointment, boredom, and having to work something out with another person. Those moments were quiet and unglamorous, and we didn’t think much about them. But they were doing something important, and we are now removing the conditions that allowed them to happen, often without noticing and often in the name of progress.
The brain doesn’t care who paid for the screen
We removed cell phones from our schools because we could see what they were doing. Whether we named it this way or not, we recognized that the technology had made distraction and disconnection too easy, too frictionless. So we decided to become the friction ourselves. We stepped in and put on the brakes because the environment required it. I think that was the right call.
I’d suggest we ask the same questions about school-issued technology, because the brain doesn’t distinguish between screens based on who paid for them. The impact of Chromebooks is quieter and harder to see, but it may be just as significant. With cell phones the disruption was visible: kids checked out of the room, connected to everything except what was in front of them. With school devices the disruption is cognitive and developmental. It happens inside the brain, in the slow erosion of attention, patience, and the capacity to sit with difficulty. It’s harder to see, and that’s exactly why it’s easier to ignore.
When we gamify a skill
When we gamify a skill, we are not always teaching the skill. We are often teaching the game. And the game activates reward pathways in ways that a teacher’s praise, a hard-earned grade, or the quiet satisfaction of working through something difficult can’t compete with. Analog learning starts to feel unbearable by comparison. Not because it is, but because the brain has been recalibrated to expect something faster, easier, and more immediately rewarding.
Foundations before tools
We see this in ways we sometimes overlook. Many schools no longer teach typing as a foundational skill, because touchscreens made it feel unnecessary. But a student who can’t type efficiently spends a lot of mental energy just getting words onto the page, energy that should go toward the actual thinking and writing. We handed them a more sophisticated tool and skipped the foundation that makes the tool useful.
That pattern repeats across subjects and grade levels, and it points to something important about developmental readiness. The question isn’t only what technology can do. It’s whether the foundational skills needed to use it well are in place first. In the younger grades, the case for screens is thin. As students develop the capacity to read deeply, write fluently, sustain attention, and tolerate difficulty, technology introduced gradually and with intention can start to add real value.
A screen in front of every child
There’s another cost I want to name, and it may be the one I think about most. The one-to-one device model, a screen in front of every child, is by design an individualizing experience. It turns each student toward their own screen and away from the room. The skills that most reliably predict long-term success, like collaboration, communication, empathy, and the ability to read and engage with other people, are built through human interaction, not solo device use. People can be trained on specific technology for a specific job. It’s much harder to teach someone in their thirties to be genuinely empathetic, to read a room, or to sit with another person’s discomfort if those capacities were never developed.
I think about the teachers who stand out most in my own memory. It was never precisely what they taught me that I remember. It was how they brought a room of people into something together: a discussion where the whole class was leaning in, an experiment we did side by side, a moment where you looked at the person next to you and you both understood something at the same time. Those memories exist because of the conditions the learning happened in. Memory consolidates around meaning and emotion, and meaning and emotion are almost always relational. A student working alone on a Chromebook isn’t going to be forty years old telling someone about the time they leveled up. There’s no shared story there. The great teacher wasn’t just delivering content. They were creating an environment, and technology as it’s often implemented works against that environment almost by design.
What’s at stake
Some of what’s at stake is measurable, and some is harder to measure. Test scores have declined over the same years that classroom devices spread, so the academic outcomes we track are a concern. So are the quieter ones. Executive functioning, emotional regulation, and the capacity to engage, connect, and persist through difficulty are among the strongest predictors of long-term wellbeing and success we know of, and they develop through exactly the conditions we’re eroding.
The question I keep returning to, in my work with families and in conversations like this one, isn’t whether technology is good or bad. It’s this: what skill am I helping this child build right now, and will it serve them in the life they’re moving toward? That question deserves a real answer before we open another Chromebook cart.
What this looks like at home
Parents can’t control what happens in a classroom, but home is full of the same choices. A few places to start:
- Leave some friction in. Waiting, boredom, a little disappointment, and working something out with a sibling are skill-building repetitions, not problems to solve right away.
- Ask what skill a screen is building. Before adding an app or a device, ask what your child is practicing, and whether the foundation is in place first.
- Protect time together. Shared, screen-free time, like dinner, a project, or a walk, is where kids practice reading people, taking turns, and staying with something hard.
This is a lot of what I work on with parents: changing the routines and environment at home so kids get the repetitions they need. How parent sessions work.
More on this: The best preparation for a digital future is an analog education, including questions you can ask your child’s school.
Next step
Start with a free 15‑minute call.
I don’t expect you to know much. Therapy is often new, and intimidating, and most people arrive without the words for what’s going on. Helping you find them is part of the work.
The form asks for a few basics: your contact information, where you’re located, and roughly what’s bringing you in. I’m accepting new clients, weekdays from 9 AM to 2 PM.
- Fill out a short intake (about 5 minutes)
- I reply within one business day
- We talk for 15 minutes, free
This opens a secure intake form through SimplePractice, the system I use for my practice. It takes about 5 minutes. It’s not a login. Please don’t send clinical or personal health details by regular email or text, because those aren’t secure. Prefer to talk first? Call (978) 219-9522. This form isn’t monitored for emergencies. If you’re in crisis, call or text 988 or call 911.